OXO Brew 8-Cup Coffee Maker 8718800 review: simple, compact, and deliberately manual

Bottom line
Model 8718800 makes the most sense for someone who wants a compact thermal brewer, values a practical 10–40 fl oz range, and does not need scheduling. The documented small-batch setup is more flexible than a carafe-only brewer, while the fixed reservoir, hand-wash carafe, filter split, and lack of programming are real tradeoffs.
OXO Brew 8-Cup Coffee Maker 8718800 review: simple, compact, and deliberately manual
The OXO Brew 8-Cup Coffee Maker covered here is the thermal-carafe model, SKU 8718800, not the newer glass-carafe model with a warming plate.[1][8]
OXO lists the thermal machine at 13.5 by 10.5 by 7 inches, and its current replacement-carafe pages still name 8718800 as the compatible brewer.[1][3][4]
One certification detail needs careful wording.[6][7] The thermal-carafe OXO 8-Cup received SCA Home Brewer certification in 2020.[6] The current SCA roster lists a 2025 OXO 8-Cup with a glass carafe, which lines up with OXO's separate glass-carafe product rather than thermal SKU 8718800.[7][8] I would not treat the old certification announcement as proof that 8718800 is currently certified.[6][7]
The short answer
This is a sensible fit if you want a compact drip machine, a thermal carafe, and batches ranging from a large mug to 40 fl oz without a pod system.[1][2] It is a poor fit if you need scheduled brewing, a hot plate, a removable water tank, or a true one-cup minimum.[1][2][9] The machine is intentionally simple, but that simplicity removes conveniences some buyers expect.[9]
No one on this editorial run owned or tested the brewer. The judgment below combines OXO's manual and product documentation with independent measurements from TechGearLab and CNET.[1][2][9] Those reviews used different protocols and test units, so their numbers describe those tests rather than every 8718800 in service.[9][10][11]
What model 8718800 actually includes
OXO calls this an eight-cup machine, but its "cup" is 5 fl oz.[2] The manual's brew range is 10–40 fl oz, or two to eight machine cups, and it explicitly says the brewer will not make less than two machine cups.[2] That makes the smallest nominal batch 10 fl oz, which is closer to one practical mug than two US measuring cups.[2]
Small batches do not use pods.[2] OXO includes an accessory that sits inside the main brew basket and takes a Kalita Wave 185 filter; the manual says it is designed for 2–4 machine cups into either a mug or the carafe.[2] Full batches use the large flat-bottom basket.[2] The controls split brewing into 2–4 and 5–8 cup ranges rather than offering a timer or a programmable start.[2][9]
The stainless-steel carafe is double-wall and vacuum insulated, and the brewer has no warming plate.[1][3] That avoids leaving coffee on an active heater, but it also means heat retention depends on the carafe.[1] OXO says to hand-wash the carafe, while TechGearLab noted that water collected around the rim when the carafe was left upside down to dry.[2][9]
Brew evidence, including the temperature conflict
TechGearLab discloses a repeatable method: a 1:18 coffee-to-water ratio, comparison against pour-over, basket-temperature readings across three cycles, and 6-cup timing across five cycles.[10]
In its OXO review, the outlet measured a 193.6°F average basket temperature and an average brew time of 5 minutes 22 seconds; it also said the basket continued dripping for roughly another minute after the completion beep.[9]
The retrievable TechGearLab review does not print SKU 8718800, so its identity is a probable thermal-model match rather than conclusive exact-SKU proof.[9]
That 193.6°F average sits below the range TechGearLab used as its benchmark, even though SCA awarded the thermal OXO 8-Cup certification in 2020.[6][9][10] There is no honest reason to erase that disagreement.[6][9] Certification shows that the submitted model passed the program's process at that time; one later publication's measurements show what happened with its unit and protocol.[6][9]
CNET's 2020 OXO Brew 8-Cup review reported an average pot-fill time of 6 minutes 8 seconds.[11]
The retrievable CNET page prints neither SKU 8718800 nor ASIN B07H9G93WK, so it is treated as a probable thermal-model match rather than exact identity proof.[11]
The difference from TechGearLab's 5:22 is not necessarily a contradiction because batch definition, timing endpoints, water, coffee dose, and unit behavior can all change the result.[9][10][11]
Treat both as bounded observations, not a promised brew time.[9][11]
Daily use
The appeal is low-friction manual brewing.[2][9] Fill the fixed reservoir with only the water you want to brew, load the appropriate paper filter and coffee, choose the small or large range, and start the cycle.[2] There is no clock-based auto-brew in the independent review's description.[9]
The fixed reservoir and top-loading basket deserve a cabinet-clearance check even though the body itself is compact.[1][2] OXO's listed dimensions are 13.5 by 10.5 by 7 inches.[1] The removable mug platform helps position shorter cups, and taller travel mugs can sit directly under the brew basket when the platform is removed.[1]
Cleaning is mostly ordinary paper-filter cleanup plus periodic descaling.[1][2] OXO lists a cleaning mode and says the removable basket, single-serve basket, scoop, well cover, and Rainmaker showerhead are top-rack dishwasher safe, but the thermal carafe should be washed by hand.[1][2]
Filters, parts, and warranty
The small accessory requires Kalita Wave 185 filters, while the large basket uses flat-bottom paper filters.[2][11] OXO currently has first-party pages for a replacement thermal carafe and replacement lid, and both pages identify 8718800 as the only compatible brewer.[3][4]
The model-specific manual states a two-year warranty for manufacturing defects on new OXO Brew appliances sold and used in the US or Canada, with proof of purchase required.[2]
Hardware revision is still unknown; the M03 text in the manual filename is treated only as a document marker.[2]
Safety
This is a high-wattage hot-water appliance, so the useful safety guidance comes from the manual rather than improvised advice.[2] OXO warns against opening the brew-basket lid during brewing, touching that area before it cools, immersing the machine, using the carafe on a range or in a microwave, or placing the brewer where it can tip from a counter.[2]
A task-local search found no exact-model CPSC or Health Canada notice for OXO 8718800.[unverified]
A negative search cannot establish that no recall exists.[unverified]
Check both regulators again before purchase if recall status matters to your decision.[unverified]
How it compares with OXO's newer glass model
Do not mix this brewer up with OXO SKU 8722000.[1][8]
OXO describes 8722000 as a glass-carafe machine with a timed warming plate and a cleaning reminder after 90 cycles.[8]
The current SCA roster's 2025 OXO 8-Cup entry also specifies a glass carafe.[7]
Those features and that roster entry should not be transferred to thermal SKU 8718800.[1][7][8]
I am not making spec comparisons with unnamed Moccamaster or Bonavita machines here. A fair table would need exact current models, equivalent source dates, and the same criteria. Without that lock, a neat-looking comparison would be more misleading than useful.
Verdict
Model 8718800 makes the most sense for someone who wants a compact thermal brewer, values a practical 10–40 fl oz range, and does not need scheduling.[1][2][9] The documented small-batch setup is more flexible than a carafe-only brewer, while the fixed reservoir, hand-wash carafe, filter split, and lack of programming are real tradeoffs.[1][2][9]
Confidence is moderate. Identity, capacity, controls, safety instructions, and the historical certification are documented by first-party sources.[1][2][6] Model-specific replacement parts are also documented.[3][4] Confidence is lower on current certification, hardware revision, long-term durability, heat retention, and universal brew performance.[6][7][9] Current price, stock, ratings, and availability are intentionally omitted.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Neutral product identifier: Amazon ASIN B07H9G93WK.[5]
No affiliate destination or tracking tag is included in this draft.
Sources
- OXO 8-Cup Coffee Maker (thermal, SKU 8718800) : source, accessed 2026-09-19
- OXO 8718800 instruction manual M03 : source, accessed 2026-09-19
- OXO replacement thermal carafe for 8718800 : source, accessed 2026-09-19
- OXO replacement thermal carafe lid for 8718800 : source, accessed 2026-09-19
- Amazon exact listing for ASIN B07H9G93WK : source, accessed 2026-09-19
- SCA 2020 certification announcement : source, accessed 2026-09-19
- SCA current Certified Home Equipment roster : source, accessed 2026-09-19
- OXO separate glass-carafe model 8722000 : source, accessed 2026-09-19
- TechGearLab OXO Brew 8-Cup review : source, accessed 2026-09-19
- TechGearLab drip coffee maker test methodology : source, accessed 2026-09-19
- CNET OXO Brew 8-Cup review : source, accessed 2026-09-19